Men fail in trials. Hearts move in many ways. We got our hands on God the Son and killed Him. Mistaken hearts called for Barabbas and sent Jesus to Golgotha. Holy Spirit gives us a new heart that sees Jesus for who He is. Our old man can be put away. (Matthew 27:11-18; Genesis 15:2-4; Jeremiah 17:9; Ephesians 4:22; Exodus 23:2; Proverbs 1:10, 14)

Speaker(s): Thomas Schaller, Gary Groenewold
Sermon 12905
Date: 2025-04-13
Time: Sunday 11:00 am

 

P. Schaller –

Okay. Praise the Lord! Praise the Lord! Amen. Praise God! Hallelujah! Hallelujah! Praise the Lord! Yes, wow! We
love fellowship, huh? We love fellowship. Man. That’s awesome. Awesome. All right.
Good morning. Praise the Lord! God is good to us. Praise God for his goodness. We have the
Word in front of us. We’re going to speak this morning. We have our Passion season is revolving
around three words: Gethsemane, Gabbatha, And Golgotha. So, you can remember those. Let’s
say them: Gethsemane, Gabbatha, and Golgotha.

So, we did last week, Gethsemane. Last few Sundays and we see how man, men fail in trials.
How we don’t have the mind of God in a trial. We don’t have the resources in a trial. In
Gethsemane, Peter took out his sword and took an ear off. Christ picked it up and healed the
man as if it had never happened. And then, he told, he said to the people arresting him, let
these go. Let these go.

And the disciples did. Peter followed afar off. And now today, we are looking at the time when
Christ is brought from the Sanhedrin where he has had two trials. One before Annas and the
second one before Caiaphas and the Sanhedrin. And they decide to bring him to Pilate and
Christ comes before Pilate. And the word there is in the English. We have pavement. The
pavement. And then, in the Hebrew it’s called Gabbatha.

The reason why they met outside was because it was a Jewish Passover and the Jews couldn’t
go into a Gentile building or else they would be defiling themselves. So, Pilate accommodated
them by bringing his judgment seat, an actual chair that came fro the inside, and put it outside
on some terrace of some kind. And there probably elevated perhaps in the context of the
crowd. There Pilate tried to manage his problem. He had a problem. Political problem
governing the Jewish people.

So, that’s a little bit of a profile of what we are going to look at today. But we have to
understand it more deeply than just the events themselves. We want to understand something
about the human heart and something about sociology, people groups, people. Something
about politics and then most importantly about ourselves.

So, I’m going, we’re going to do a little work before we get to the message and that is Genesis
chapter 15:2. Maybe some people would say this is an unlikely verse to relate but it is, and it
relates. So, we’ll start from vs. 1. Genesis 15:1-2. I have no children. What am I going to do
about this promise that I will be the father of a great nation? How can that be? I have a servant.
His name is Eleazar in vs. 2.

I don’t have a child, but I have a servant. Would that work? He’s from Damascus. He’s not a Jew
like me. You called me, but could we put Eleazar in there to be a family member. We kind of
adopt him into the family and just say he’s my son. And the Lord answered and said, No.
Vs. 4. Now in there in that picture we have a promise. We have a promise, but I can’t see how
it’s going to work. So, I plug in the natural. Like let’s work this out my way and the Lord said, no.
You’re going to have a child, but I counter and say I’m an old man and my wife is old, too. How
can it happen? And the Lord is saying to all of us, believe me. Trust me. I’m going to give you –
this is going to happen. What I promised is going to happen.

The next verse I want you to see is Jeremiah 17:9. We had a pastor and trustee retreat this past
weekend and we enjoyed it very much being together. And our theme was what do we do well
or how do we, what is it in our ministry that God does? Where is his hand in the things that we
do? What do we do well? And we all basically I hope when I’m done this morning you will
understand a little bit what the ministry is. What is it essentially. What is the ministry? Not
simply us but like this church but all through history. What essentially is the ministry of God to
our hearts?

Jeremiah 17:9, Now, the word “deceitful” could be illustrated many ways. It’s how my heart kind of
cheats. Sometimes, very blatantly and openly and sometimes more subtly inside, in my
reasoning, in my thoughtfulness. I kind of twist a thing that might be wrong, or it is wrong, but I
can twist it and say it’s not that wrong. It’s not that bad. Or I can say about a good thing, it’s – I
could take a good thing and twist and say it is bad. I can take a bad thing and twist it and say it
is good. It’s Isaiah 5:20.

And so, we have a description of who we are and that we can’t even know our own
motivations. Sometimes, I don’t really know how clean I am in my motivation. I might do
something because people are watching, or I might have an opinion because it’s to my
advantage. My opinion, my way of seeing it might protect me. I don’t want to be vulnerable.
I might protect myself by excusing myself, blaming another, finding fault with you to protect
myself. Our hearts move in many ways. We all know about maybe gifted people who are very
ambition and very good and very successful and maybe very wealthy and they might give their
money away just simply because they want to be known as a philanthropist. And I want my
name to be known that way.

So, it says in 1 Corinthians 13 though I give my money to feed the poor and I have not love, it profits
me nothing. Why? Because God searches our hearts, finds out what is our motivation. God
knows what is in us. And there isn’t anything more clear to me as a story as we see at the
Passion when Christ, the Son of God is despised. It says that in Isaiah 52 and 53 that he was
despised and rejected of men and that we hid our faces from him. We hid our, we hid our, we consider Jesus before Pilate as a throwaway. We despised him and hid our faces from him and
just didn’t care about him.

Didn’t he raise the dead and heal the leper and heal the blind and feed the thousands? And
wasn’t he a popular character and didn’t we see the things he did and understand it? It’s like,
yes. Yes. But, but everybody in Jerusalem was crying out Barabbas, Barabbas.
So, let’s turn to Ephesians 4. It’s kind of, I know it’s a downer but it’s good for us. I hope it is. I hope
you could hear this and follow it. Chapter 4:21. Pray with me for a moment. (Prayer).

Vs. 21-22. So, there you have that phrase, “old man.” The old man. Who is the old man but the first
Adam? Who was the first Adam?
He was in the Garden of Eden and in his sin, when he sinned, he was attracted – Adam and Eve
was attracted to the tree. Well, it says Eve was. And what she was attracted to were three
things. One, it’s good for food. That’s the part of our design. We have to eat. We want to eat.

#2. It’s a beautiful tree. That’s something built in us, too.We recognize beautiful things like a beautiful landscape, a beautiful child, a beautiful woman, a beautiful scene, artwork. We have an attraction to the beautiful. And then thirdly, intelligence. The tree will make you wise. You’ll become like a god. You will know good and evil. That’s what
the devil said to Eve. All three of those things are attracted, we are attracted to in our sin
nature.

And this is our old man. Our old man defends himself, protects himself, deflects blame, wants
to come out clean in the eyes of other people. Wants to be intelligent. Appreciate the beautiful
things and we want to eat all that is good. There’s simply a problem in my nature, in my heart. I
have something in my heart and by nature I’m against God. That’s the old man. He is a sinner
and he’s against God. Romans 3:10-18 is a great description of who we are in our hearts.

So, in the text we’re going to read is Matthew 27. This is about the crowd crying out in chapter 27:11.
I am. We could say he is saying, I am. He never denied it. I am the king of the Jews. While he
was being accused by the chief priests and elders, he answered nothing. Vs. 12-14. Why didn’t
Christ defend himself? He came for this reason. Why didn’t he call down 10,000 angels? He
came for this reason to die for us, to pay for our sin, to atone for our sin by his shed blood. As
you see in your Bible all the way from the beginning.

We see from Adam and Eve that God killed animals and clothed them with the skins. Well, to do
that you shed blood. You cannot skin an animal without blood. And you cannot do it really
without killing the animal. That foreshadowed what would come, when Christ himself would
come as the Lamb of God that would take away the sin of the world.

But what we’re studying here is something also about us and how we’re kind of hiding in the
whole picture and we are going to cry out for Barabbas to be set free. Not Christ but Barabbas.
Vs. 15-16. Bar means “son of” and Abbas is “son of the father.” He’s son of the father. And it’s
interesting because some historians have pointed out that he was actually called Jesus. Jesus
Barabbas would be Jesus the son of the father.

He was somebody that was very guilty of crimes. I actually read that Pilate at that moment was thinking of how to manage it and get Jesus off the hook. So, he’s in his mind knowing the prisoners that are in the prison that have been
arrested, and undoubtedly the most notorious, the most wicked, the worst is the first one that
maybe comes to his mind. Who will we release instead of – how could we release Jesus? How
about if we take the most “baddest” guy? The most notorious criminal, the murderer, and offer
him up. Surely the crowd would not say, Barabbas. They would say release Jesus. Crucify
Barabbas. Crucify Barabbas and let Jesus go free.

Nice try, Pilate. Not going to work. Cuz there’s something at work in our hearts in the crowd
that is very real in our lives and that is the old man is very real part of our life and how we can
get things wrong when it comes to God and his work and his will.

It says put off the old man and put on the new man, Ephesians 4:21-25 in that text. Read vs. 16-19.
Wow! He’s getting a warning from his wife. She had a dream. Isn’t that fascinating? Did the
dream come from God? I mean where did the dream come from? She had heard about him.
He’s a just man. And her influence on Pilate undoubtedly led him to think that how can I get out
of this? I really don’t want to crucify him. But the crowd, vs. 20.

Could we put up Exodus 23:2 and read this verse about running with the crowd. How does it go? Vs.
2. Twist judgment. Wrest judgment. Sometimes, you see on the TV a riot. Would you run with
the riot? Would you run with the crowd to do evil? Maybe you would say, no. I don’t want to do
any evil but I’m with the group and the group is kind of overcoming me. It has an influence on
me. I’m running with the crowd.

It says in Proverbs 1. Maybe we can put that verse up. Try Proverbs 1:10, it takes a second to get up
there. Yes, it is that one. Vs. 10-11. They also say put your money in together with us. Where is
that? Let’s go together with one purse, vs. 14. Like you all know how you could get into some
kind of business deal and you put your money together and now you find out it’s not going
good. There’s some kind of criminal activity or unjust or somebody is going to get – I want to
get out. I can’t get out because I put my money in. I want to get out but how do I get out? I’m
running with the group, so they’re going to cry out, Barabbas!

And if you were in that group and I was in that group, very possibly I would also, I would be
indifferent maybe. I might cry out. I’m in the influence of the group. I’m part of the group. I’m
running with the group. My heart is, maybe my heart, I don’t know any better. I just have the old man that is in that place where I need to make a hard decision, but I can’t make it ’cause the
old man, his heart is deceitful.

A guy that is in charge of a non-profit that starts it really with a pure and good intentions and
maybe also maybe in the ministry a man or woman get involved and they find themselves not
able to handle what is really being called upon them. And the guy that started the non-profit
starts to take money. Or the pastor who is after – he started but then he burns out. Or he gets
into a relationship with somebody that he shouldn’t be with.

You might stand back and say; how could that happen? How could that happen? How is it that
people change? How could it start well and end bad? The answer is our hearts. Our hearts. You
see, there’s two of them. There’s the old man and his heart and then we have the new birth.
We have Christ born in us. And don’t think of it just as a theological concept but to grab ahold
of it and know it in your heart in a personal way. The Holy Spirit is in us. We have a new heart.
And we’re able to say, we’re able to recognize I’m not part of this.

I see in that man something. I see you guys are throwing him away, but I see in him who he is. That’s when he entered into Jerusalem on the donkey. And one cowboy said if you ride on the young donkey that has never
been ridden, it will automatically get rid of the rider. It will throw the rider. There’s no question
about it. That donkey should have thrown Jesus off, but it didn’t because he’s the Messiah. He
has the authority over the animal. No, he is the Christ, the Messiah that’s coming back one day
and before he comes, he had to pay for our sin as being a silent lamb who’s subject to the
judgments of the old man, who says basically, Barabbas! We’ll take Barabbas. Set Barabbas
free.

Pilate is saying – I think. Maybe. We don’t know. I’m just suggesting that he’s thinking in his
heart your envy is blinding you. You don’t like him. You hate him. You’re envious of him. You
don’t know, I don’t know, Pilate didn’t know who he was. But he did know that he was
delivered up because of envy.

Do you know, do you and I know that a lot of things happen in life are the result of bad
judgments? Do you and I realize that people have opinions because those are the opinions of
the first man, first Adam? Like Abraham said, I’m going to be the father of a great nation, but I
don’t have any children. How about Eleazer? How about Eleazer? And God said, no. Not going
to cut it. It’s going to happen from your own body. I will do it. I am God. I want you to know me.
But you have to also realize how prone we are to error and substitution.

One thing I mentioned. I don’t know where I heard it but this phrase, “Woke Christianity.” Like
Woke Christianity. What is it? I don’t even want to try to define it. You can use your own mind
on that, but I want to say simply when I want to get out of my responsibility, when I want to not
face the reality, when I want it my way; when I invent my idea of what is right and wrong, then I’m a person that could easily cry out we want Barabbas. I’m making a mistake and it’s from my
own heart. I’m blind to the real big issues and that is the reality of God as a person.

Let’s close with that thought. What do I do when I got the old man, the old man. That guy that’s
going to say – he can say many things like I fell in love with another woman. Or my kids. I’m
frustrated with my kids. They’re not that important to me anymore. My kids don’t love me, so I
don’t love them. It’s a horrible thought. What is the heart of man and how does he process it?
My neighborhood. I don’t like where I live. My job. I mean we all can understand that we don’t
love, you know. I understand. At the same time, check yourself. Like they might not be the
problem. Your wife may not be the problem. It’s your heart. Your kids are not the problem. It’s
your heart. My country is not the problem. It’s my heart.

Before I judge my country, my neighbors, my wife, my family, my church, my pastor, the Word
of God and anything and everything else. My friends. Before I do that, I better check wait a
minute. Am I crying out for Barabbas to go free? Am I saying crucify Jesus cuz that’s the
answer? Before I make my judgments on things, let me check my own heart. ‘Cause I am prone to
getting things upside down. So, this is it.

I’ll just say I go to the closet. There’s Gabbatha. The human race is making a judgment on Christ
and we’re going to get it wrong. So, there it is. That’s wrong. The whole crowd. Why am I crying
out, Barabbas! Barabbas! Because I don’t want to be different from the crowd. The majority
wins. I want to be with the majority. Careful of that. You’re running with a multitude to do evil.
You can hang people. Literally. Historically. Hanging people. A crowd. A village. A town. Taking
justice in their own hands. Vigilantes. Running with the crowd. A riot. Burning cars. Tearing
down buildings. Hurting people. Running with the crowd. It can happen.

But, no. Wait a minute. I want to have a walk with God. I can be wrong. So, I go over here to my
closet. Closet is the prayer. Prayer closet, Matthew 6. We come before God and say God, I can be
wrong. Maybe I am. I want to get prepared in my life. Fill me with the Spirit all the time. Teach
me your Word. Let me get your mind. I need people around me that are wise, that are loving,
that are edifying. I will learn love. Help me. Teach me love.

By the way, do you know how you learn love? By a person loving you. Simple illustration. A child
born. The child needs mom. Needs love. Needs care. When they are two years old, they need a
person. They need love. They need care. They need a dad. They need a mom. They need an
uncle. They need a grandfather. They need a grandmother. They need to be loved. When
they’re seven years old, they need to be loved. They need to learn love. They need to learn
about it.

What about a believer? He needs love. I need God to love me. I need you to love me. I need my
sisters and brothers to love me. I need the truth. Not only like love but love in truth. God is
true. So, here we are in prayer. I’m bringing my envy to him. I’m emptying my pockets so to
speak. Lord, I got some envy in here. Here you go. I got some jealousy over here. I got
covetousness. I got lust in my heart. I’m bringing all of this before you. And I’m putting off the
old man.

Let’s take this coat and put off the old man. You’re the one. You want Barabbas. I know you.
You’re going to call out for Barabbas. Well, you can take a hike. You’re at the cross. I don’t want
to live in that. Can you say that? I don’t want to live in that but help me.
So, that’s why you’re here today. You want to hear about it. You want to hear about God, his
Spirit, his nature, his way. So, fill me with your Spirit. Teach me your Word. Help me make right
judgments about things. And then, we become edifying. And we learn about it.

So, I have both of them happening in my heart. I get upset. I get worked up. I have the old man
and he’s alive and he’s affecting me in my opinion and my decisions and my judgment on
people. I can be really hard. I can be self-righteous. They were very self-righteous when they
cried out, Barabbas! They were Pharisees. They wanted to get rid of Jesus. He’s a problem. And
they call out for an evil man, a wicked man. Barabbas. Wow.

So, can I do that? But I don’t want to be that way. That old man to be replaced by the new man
and walking. Put on the new man. Walking in the new life. That new mind and heart. So, now
we look at not just ministry, but we look at a flower. God is here. Look at a child. A bird flying in
the sky. You start to be thankful. You start to love people cuz that’s the nature of God and we
believe God. We’re on the same team and we walk in the Spirit and we learn that lesson that I
am the one that cried out, Barabbas! But not any more by God’s grace.

And I will do it because of my flesh or my old man is capable, and I can make very tough, hard
evaluations and decisions about things and get it wrong. I can be wrong. I need to know that.
So, then I can come in my prayer in faith and ask him to help me and fill me and teach me.
Okay. Amen.

 

Please enjoy these sermon notes from the messages preached at Greater Grace Church in Baltimore. These notes are provided to aid in your study and understanding of the Word. Note that these notes do not represent complete, word-for-word transcriptions. Also, they may contain omissions as well as some errors in spelling and structure, etc., as we attempt to provide them as soon as possible. Our hope is that these notes serve as a way to help you search and connect with messages on related subjects and passages. Thank you for your interest in the ministry of Greater Grace.